Market intelligence

How to buy an insurance agency or book of business

Where agencies and books of business for sale come from, how buyers reach owners before they list, and how to find producers licensed 30+ years.

How to buy an insurance agency or book of business: 42,785 producers have been licensed for 30 years or more.

An agency or a book of business

Buying an insurance agency means taking over a business: its clients, carrier contracts, staff, office and name. Buying a book of business means taking over the clients and the renewal commissions they pay, and serving them from your own agency. A book is a common first purchase for a producer who wants to grow faster than new sales allow, and it is how many agencies add a line they do not write yet.

Captive books work differently. The carrier controls the policies, so a captive agent can sell only with the carrier's approval and to a buyer the carrier appoints, and some carriers do not let their agents sell at all. Captive vs. independent agents explains the two models.

Where agencies for sale come from

Listings are the visible part of the market. Agency marketplaces, business brokers and M&A advisors post insurance agencies and books of business for sale, and many buyers wait for the right one to appear. Many deals never reach a listing: an owner who wants to retire, or a producer leaving the business, often sells to someone they already know, such as a producer in the office, a local competitor or the buyer who called first.

The largest buyers do not wait. Aggregators and brokers backed by private equity run outreach programs that reach owners before they decide to sell, which is how the largest insurance brokers keep growing. A smaller buyer who reaches owners first gets the conversations that never become listings.

Find the owners most likely to sell

Retirement is one of the most common reasons to sell, and years licensed is the closest thing a license file has to age. In our agent file 42,785 of the 1,186,056 producers have been licensed for 30 years or more, and 136,147 for 20 years or more. 28,444 of the 30-year producers list a business email.

years_licensed counts from the issue date on the record, so for some producers it is shorter than their whole career: read 30 years as at least 30. 4% of producers have no issue date and are left out of these counts.

Funnel: 1,186,056 producers; 42,785 licensed 30 years or more; 28,444 of those with a business email; 6,880 of those at a small agency with five producers or fewer on its own email domain.
Each step is a filter on the served columns. years_licensed counts from the issue date on the record, so read 30 years as at least 30.

Small agencies run by a long-licensed producer

Most agencies are small, and a small agency is often run by its most experienced producer. Grouped by the domain of their business email, 68,286 business domains have five producers or fewer, leaving out personal mailboxes, carriers, banks, call centers and the large brokers. In 6,277 of them the longest-licensed producer has 30 years or more, and 3,496 of those are one-producer offices.

Those are the agencies where the succession question is close, and where an owner with no successor in the office may welcome a buyer who calls first. Most of them will not sell this year. The point of a list is to start those conversations early, so that you are the buyer the owner already knows.

Bar chart of 68,286 business email domains with five producers or fewer, by the years licensed of the longest-licensed producer on each: under 10 years 32,460, 10 to 20 years 17,491, 20 to 30 years 11,885, 30 years or more 6,277.
3,496 of the 6,277 agencies led by a producer licensed 30+ years have one producer. Personal mailboxes, carriers, banks, call centers and the large brokers are left out.

Build the outreach list

Start with the market you can serve: the state pack for your territory, or the nationwide file if you buy across states. Filter years_licensed to 25 or 30 and more, and keep the producers whose license matches your book: is_property_casualty for a P&C agency, is_life_health for a life or benefits book. Group the rows with a business domain by that domain, and keep the longest-licensed producer on each as the likely owner; agency_name, where present, names the agency. Many small owners use a personal mailbox instead, so keep those rows as they are and use the address to place them.

Then write to each owner personally. Say who you are, what you would keep (the staff, the name, the office) and that you are asking early. Expect most to say not now, and note who says later. The experienced agents list has every producer licensed ten years or more if you want a wider pool.

Price, check and close

Agencies and books are priced on their revenue or their earnings: the commissions the book pays each year, and what is left after the cost of servicing it. Retention, the mix of lines, growth, the carrier contracts and how much of the book depends on the seller all move the price. Many deals pay part of the price later, tied to how many clients stay, or let the seller finance part of it.

Before closing, check the commission statements against what the carriers paid, the carrier contracts and whether they can be assigned, the E&O history and every producer's licenses. The buying agency needs a license in each client's state and appointments with the carriers on the book, or a plan to move clients to its own carriers at renewal. Agree a transition period too: the seller introducing you to clients keeps more of them than any letter.

Four steps: find owners and start conversations early; value the book on its revenue or earnings, retention and line mix; check the commissions, carrier contracts, E&O history and licenses; close, take over the carrier appointments and have the seller introduce the clients.
Most of the work is the first step: owners usually sell to a buyer they already know.

Start with one market

A state pack is $149 and the nationwide file $699. The Texas pack alone has 14,351 producers licensed 30 years or more, and the Florida pack 14,649. Download the free 1,000-row sample to check the columns before you buy.

Back to the resource library

Check it yourself first

Open the sample before you spend anything.

insurance-agents-free-sample.csv1,000 real records · 21 columns · all 50 states + DCDownload free sample

Same columns as the paid packs. No signup and no email required. Or browse the state packs